Chargebee vs Recurly: Which Billing Platform Has Better Dunning?

Both billing platforms include dunning, but neither is as capable as dedicated recovery tools. A fair comparison of built-in options.

Quick Verdict

Both offer competent but basic dunning within their billing ecosystems. Chargebee has the edge with cancel-flow surveys; Recurly has better retry optimization with Revenue Optimizer. Neither offers AI voice calls or AI email generation. If recovery is a priority, supplement either platform with a dedicated tool like Rezoki.

Overview

Chargebee Retention

Retention module within Chargebee's subscription billing platform. Cancel-flow surveys, email dunning, and configurable retry rules for Chargebee users.

Pricing: Included in Chargebee plans ($249+/month for billing)

Best for: Companies committed to Chargebee for subscription billing

Recurly Dunning

Built-in dunning management within Recurly's subscription billing platform. Email sequences, retry scheduling, and account updater integration.

Pricing: Included in Recurly (Core: $0 + 0.9% of revenue, Pro: custom)

Best for: Companies committed to Recurly for subscription billing

Detailed Feature Comparison

FeatureChargebee RetentionRecurly Dunning
Cancel Flow SurveysBuilt-inNot available
Account UpdaterAvailableIntegrated
Email DunningTemplate-basedTemplate-based
Retry OptimizationConfigurable rulesRevenue Optimizer (ML)
Voice CallsNot availableNot available
Base Platform Cost$249+/month$0 + 0.9% revenue
Advanced Dunning TierProfessional+Professional+
Email CustomizationModerateLimited
Multi-Currency SupportComprehensiveGood
Standalone DunningPlatform requiredPlatform required

Pros & Cons

Chargebee Retention

Pros

  • Cancel-flow surveys and offboarding
  • Configurable retry rules
  • Integrated with Chargebee billing
  • Smart dunning on higher tiers

Cons

  • Requires Chargebee billing ($249+/mo)
  • Advanced dunning on higher tiers only
  • No AI voice calls
  • Complex setup

Recurly Dunning

Pros

  • Account updater integration
  • Revenue optimizer (retry timing)
  • Integrated with Recurly billing
  • Configurable dunning schedules

Cons

  • Requires Recurly platform + 0.9% of revenue
  • Advanced dunning on higher tiers
  • No AI voice calls
  • Limited email customization

Pricing Comparison

Chargebee Retention

Included in Chargebee plans ($249+/month for billing)

Recurly Dunning

Included in Recurly (Core: $0 + 0.9% of revenue, Pro: custom)

Who Should Choose What?

Choose Chargebee Retention if:

Companies committed to Chargebee for subscription billing

Choose Recurly Dunning if:

Companies committed to Recurly for subscription billing

Which billing platform should I choose for better dunning?+
Don't choose a billing platform based on dunning alone. Choose based on billing features, pricing, and developer experience. Then add a dedicated recovery tool like Rezoki for maximum dunning performance.
Can I use an external dunning tool with Chargebee or Recurly?+
Yes, though integration may vary. Rezoki integrates with Stripe — if either billing platform processes through Stripe, you may be able to add Rezoki for enhanced recovery.
Is built-in dunning good enough?+
For basic recovery, yes. But built-in dunning from billing platforms typically recovers less than dedicated tools. Adding AI voice calls alone (via Rezoki) can increase recovery by 15-30%.
Which has better retry logic?+
Recurly's Revenue Optimizer uses machine learning for retry timing, giving it an edge over Chargebee's rule-based approach on higher tiers. However, neither matches dedicated recovery tools.
Are there better alternatives to both?+
For dunning specifically, yes. Dedicated tools like Rezoki offer AI voice calls, AI email generation, and ML retries that neither Chargebee nor Recurly provide. Consider using your billing platform for billing and Rezoki for recovery.

Looking for the Best Recovery Tool?

Rezoki is the only revenue recovery platform with AI voice calls, AI email sequences, and ML-powered retries. Set up in 5 minutes with one Stripe webhook.

Try Rezoki FreeView all comparisons

Stop Losing Revenue to Failed Payments

Rezoki recovers failed payments automatically with AI-powered emails and voice calls. Set up in 5 minutes.

Start Recovering RevenueSee How It Works